Eight Tossed From Local Races
Supreme Court ruling gives re-election to four incumbents.
Eight candidates in Charleston County races are off the ballots today after party leaders determined they did not file the proper financial disclosure paperwork.
The removals come after the South Carolina Supreme Court ruled candidates who did not file financial disclosure paperwork must come off the ballot.
Locally, Democrats are feeling the pinch most severely. Six local Dems were tossed from the ballot, according to party records. Only two Republican candidates in Charleston County were affected by the decision.
Democrats off the ballot:
See full statewide list.
Master Bines (State Senate No. 42)
Larry Carter Center (State House No. 114)
Frederick Fielding (State Senate No. 42)
John Polk (County Council No. 3)
Anthony Mark Whisenant (Sheriff)
Melva Zinaich (Auditor)
Republicans off the ballot:
See full statewide list.
Chris Cannon (State House No. 119)
John Steinberger (State Senate No. 41)
"It's unfortunate. The candidates were following instructions from the ethics committee and everyone was acting in good faith," said Charleston Democratic Party Chairman Richard Hricick.
Though the rulling impacts Democrats in Charleston County disproportionately, it's not a political issue, he said.
"I don't see this as a partisan decision," Hricick said. "It disproportinately affected non-incumbents."
Charleston County GOP Chair Lyn Bennett said Republicans were as upset by the decision as their Democratic counterparts.
"This whole thing has my head swmming," Bennett said.
She said the party tried to ensure everyone who filed as a candidate follwed the proper procedure, she told everyone who filed as a challenger they needed to provide the party with their EIC number, which they get when they file their Statement of Economic Interest forms, when they filed their Statement of Intention of Candidacy forms with the party.
"Everyone had an EIC number, so I'm not sure how they got that without filing the forms," Bennet said.
Hricik said the take away lesson for both parties, and future candidates, moving forward is the confluence of new technology and the letter of the law doesn't also flow smoothly.
"When you can file so much online I don't think everyone realized you'd have to also file the paper copies as well," he said.
If the ruling stands, it's good news for five Charleston County incumbents who no longer face opposition. Charleston County Sheriff Al Cannon, State Sen. Robert Ford, House Speaker Bobby Harrell and County Commissioner Elliott Summey all effectively won re-election with the ruling, since the only opposition they faced was from a Democrat in November.
All of the candidates could still run as petition candidates if they choose, but to do so they will have to collect signatures from 5 percent of the registered voters in their district to appear on ballots.
"I'm sure we'll have lots of members in our party supporting the candidates that want to run as petition candidates," Bennett said.
"Right now the question is if there is a way to get them on the ballots as Democrats as they filed," Hricik said.
Statewide, 95 Democrats and 88 Republicans were removed from ballots.
William J. Hamilton
9:59 am on Monday, May 7, 2012
Most of these disqualified candidates did exactly what the State Election Commission told them to do. Filing their disclosure online and putting the number, which functioned as a proof of filing on their other forms. This meant their form and information were instantly available to the public. The only way to obtain the "form" required was to fill it out online and then print out a copy to file with the other paperwork. Candidates were told that was unnecessary and inappropriate because the forms were no longer filed on paper.
The lesson here is that the people in power in South Carolina cannot be trusted in even the most basic aspects of the election process and thousands of Charleston County residents no longer have any meaningful options when they go to the polls. Incumbents always tend to get reelected. Now they don't even have to be bothered to campaign. Utterly rotten.